Cloudflare tunnel vs tailscale reddit

0/24 with your actual subnet) then in the tailscale admin portal you would need to accept that route to be advertised. CloudFlare Tunnel is installed and running using the Docker app on the NAS, and it's configured in CF dashboard to connect to "1. 1 so it can't fully replace Cloudflare Tunnels without using a proxy. 1:1000", but clicking a button on the page that is supposed to But one thing was made abundantly clear in that thread: don't use Cloudflare tunnels for non-html content! In this latest update, the Cloudflare Tunnel has been replaced with a VPS Tailscale tunnel here. JF is against CF terms, they are slowing you on purpose. My local ISP has stupid routing. 3) Self hosted VPN tunnel. Something about tailscale makes me uneasy, and openvpn has been a pita for me. WireGuard is a breath of fresh air imo. This connectivity is made possible through our lightweight, open-source connector, cloudflared. WireGuard is the way to go. Introducing: Cosmos-Server! 🚀 Cosmos is a secure and easy-to-use self-hosted platform that acts as a gateway to your applications, ensuring their safety and If headscale is behind a reverse proxy, make sure it is configured to pass WebSockets through’. Cloudflare (I assume you're talking about their tunnels?) is a convenient way of providing public access to your machines. Reply. That bit prevents them from having any packet-level So, that is not a security concern, but I would like to know security wise if Tailscale is worth it. I have set up tailscale for remote access with a mapped network drive. The most significant performance difference is on Linux. Twingate was many times faster than tailscale. gelli and finamp both implement some subset of music playing features but neither integrates with various android core stuff like carplay We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This can help to reduce the attack surface of your network, as you are not exposing any ports directly to the internet. com and support. Enough that I turned the tunnel off and went looking for another solution. Also, it can be easy to shoot yourself in the foot with misconfigured policies. Cloudflare Tunnels are designed to allow you to make private resources available publically. Great for self hosting / accessing GUIs remotely - offers authentication. Traffic between devices using Tailscale is end-to-end encrypted, meaning no one at Tailscale can see what you If I install and setup Tailscale Client (subnet routing & exit node) on the RPi4, and then try to disable port forwarding on the router and delete the WireGuard Server while I'm connected to the network via Tailscale, will this be successful or you think I may completely lose connection while deleting the pre-existing WireGuard Server? That was mostly because of the way I have my network setup with custom inbound and outbound rules. 167. As such, both offer a secure tunnel to access your private network—and both come with a free version. WARP tunnel is essentially an overlay network (like tailscale but a bit different) using wireguard and you do NOT need to add firewall rules to use it. ZeroTier using this comparison chart. Can be used with Tailscale's official open source client. Please note that in Nginx I do have Websocket support, Block Common Exploits, Cache Assets, and all SSL Certificate sliders are turned on. Tailscale vs. CF dynamic DNS, with CF proxy, NGINX in the house. That may seem like the case, but I would argue that all the bells and whistles (ACLs, Magic DNS, Subnet Router) Tailscale provides are more complicated than the actual Wireguard setup itself. Cloudflare Tunnel and reverse proxies are two different things. Put tailscale on Raspberry Pi, but launch it with sudo tailscale up --advertise-routes=192. ) or it can be a simple IP tunnel if you're just going to forward HTTPS connections through it. Tailscale - Built on WireGuard. CF Tunnel can land on the home index. g. I'm also using a Cloudflare tunnel to connect to an Uptime Kuma container hosted on an Oracle Cloud VPS (more below). Tailscale makes this pretty simple to grant new users access. The Cloudflare connector is a service as well r/homeassistant. I want to point out another option that few people in the homelab/selfhosted community seem to talk about. Try to ping any of your subdomains (ping https://xxx. Especially if you need to keep QuickConnect enabled anyway for some Synology apps and stuff. I've both the setup, depending on the use case. Tailscale is nice because it can make it super easy to establish the tunnel, basically you just install it and say tailscale up on both ends, then your home server and the VPS can "see Note: not sure that putting tailscale and cloudflare tunnel in the same bucket was the right choice, I believe they solve different things, but I am not 100% certain. I was able to get Tailscale set up on IOS and the unraid server but can't bridge the connection between the iphone and immich unless the phone is connected to the network. I know I can block out countries from access, but doing a tunnel still opens up my HA computer directly to the internet. The container keep searching for any update in every start Free Ngrok alternative with Cloudflare Tunnels. Love wireguard, hate the manual setup. Share Add a Comment ZeroTier is a decentralized network virtualization platform. Pivpn + duckdns + pfsense is my setup. Tailscale is very simple to setup. Email nags about needing to update the connector and having to go through all that. com" properly displays "1. 296K Members. I like the idea of being able to connect to my server with a simple URL. This may be true in your case as well. 21K subscribers in the CloudFlare community. It connects your Home Assistant Instance via a secure tunnel to a domain or subdomain at Cloudflare. Additionally, you can utilize Cloudflare Zero Trust to further secure your connection. Zerotier is, I understand, another alternative. They offer a custom-made protocol that has 2 virtualization layers: “Virtual Layer 1” (VL1) is the peer-to-peer network backbone which encrypts communications, ensures endpoint authentication, and Cloudflare tunnels can be a useful way to securely expose services running on your home network to the internet without the need for port forwarding on your router. Their tagline is “decentralize until it hurts, then centralize until it works. 63 workstation foo@ linux idle, tx 7022084 rx 462972. #3. Cloudflare tunnels aren't quite a VPN and are more comparable to opening an SSH tunnel or ngrok as I understand it. Tailscale lets me tunnel data from home to the node securely and I then use NPM to redirect traffic and for easy SSL certificates via the CloudFlare token system. One major problem of OpenVPN is single threaded operation, making it difficult to scale. EX: "www. 316 Online. Twingate and Tailscale are each VPNs, with similar pitches about ease-of-use and remote When I visit the domain Cloudflare Tunnel appears to be proxying traffic to the website hosted at port 8000 regardless of whether I am on the Tailscale network of nog. Cloudflare tunnels creates a tunnel between you and cloudflare, meaning you can lockdown your firewall to let nothing else in other than cloudflare and your own ssh connections. Read on to find out how the two solutions compare. I'd like to create subdomains of this domain for the services I'm hosting. This could be a VPS on a cloud hosting provider like Linode or Digital Ocean etc. Tailscale is a VPN manager, so only you would have access to your network. Twingate's connector is ok, but flaky in my experience. Tailscale is a good product and made by smart people but it's Open Source only in marketing speech. 2 options to open up WireGuard: Tunnel from a Cloudflare tunnel proxy into a docker container host Open a port on router and forward When I visit the domain Cloudflare Tunnel appears to be proxying traffic to the website hosted at port 8000 regardless of whether I am on the Tailscale network of nog. 4. yourdomain. For whatever reason, VPN cramps limits network speed so incredibly bad and VPN is flaky on staying connected, even when using apps like Viscosity w/ OpenVPN. Then it can reverse proxy the HTTP requests to a local non-HTTPS webserver. Performance. Tailscale's architecture means that if the cloud goes down, it just keeps functioning with last known good configuration. (Plex and transmission have a open ports in router). Tailscale makes it ridiculously simple to get up and running with Wireguard. This is true regardless of auth on a reverse proxy bc that auth process is also very potentially exploitable and has to be kept up to date to patch exploits. Well I'm sure they'd prefer people not abuse it, but not that i'm aware of, and have never seen any mention of people being banned. When it comes to usability, maintainability, and security options, Tailscale and OpenVPN differ vastly. domain. Using WireGuard directly offers better performance than using Tailscale. It enables you to access your service through a tunnel using cloudflare directly instead of using tailscale. It's definitely worth learning if you're ever going to set up something for a business or organization in the future in terminal/ssh to nas you would need to something like this: sudo tailscale up --advertise-exit-node --advertise-routes 192. Tailscale using this comparison chart. Direct link to my cloud instance in Frankfurt has an average speed of 60 Mbit/s, but when I use CloudFlare WARP the speed exceeds 200 Mbit/s. Same here goes for most of the mesh VPN providers. Looks like the tailscale website is down right now. 5 million rows of data took about 3 minutes over twingate. Compare price, features, and reviews of the software side-by-side to make the best choice for your business. I installed Tailscale on my RPi K3s cluster (it worked immediately with just a few steps and is amazing FYI) and now I can access my home services from anywhere by visiting <cluster_ip>:<port>. com Straight wireguard is going to give you better performance as it uses the kernel implementation and not the userspace wireguard. Cloudflare tunnels are also good. Techradar says. Hi All, So currently the way I operate is that I have two domains held with Cloudflare and also have DNS in Cloudflare and connected over an Argo Tunnel to my Docker host which runs SWAG (Nginx) which handles web connections and the SSL certs for the domain, I then route access to specific services over to an Authelia container to handle the access control and 2FA etc. RaidOwl has a fantastic video on how to set this up called “No more CloudFlare Tunnels for me”. Felt like they had not improved upon that for 2 years. On nodes where Tailscale Funnel is enabled you’ll see them in tailscale status --json. Nov 17, 2022 · The second thing we do is add those Funnel ingress nodes to your tailnet’s list of Tailscale peers. I have a CF tunnel in a docker container that acts as a proxy for my requests to an ESP32 from which I get the temperature data on my phone when I need it. Really depends on what you're trying to do and how easy you need/want it to be and if it's worth the performance hit. Previously, access was only possible . Just going through the process a first time set up for A DS923+ and have a question about multiple users accessing a file. I am favoring Ngrok due to ease of sharing, but not sure on the security of Ngrok. Cloudflare used for making sure that approved IP can use services i host. Voila - Tailscale solved 100% of that issue and solved my initial use case of accessing Jellyfin from my own devices when outside of my LAN. That paragraph only mentioned kernel space vs user space implementation, kernel space is always faster. Now, I have a domain pointing to cloudflare and yesterday I sucessfully configured a tunnel to one of my docker services. Thanks :) QuickConnect is probably better than the free CloudFlare tier. The guides I have found so far about setting up tunnels do not use a reverse proxy. However I would prefer to use Tailscale to access my services, and not use cloudflare tunnels. It also says Tailscale is faster than other non Wireguard based VPN, so it's in general faster than OpenVPN as well. Until and unless you need more control on the reverse proxy, it's linear to use clouldflared proxying your backend. What I'm looking for is How to connect some devices from RI to Alexa and vice versa. I'm running this same use case right now with no issues. It’s literally as simple as running a tunnel docker container that is on the same network as the app you want to expose. using TailsScale, NGINX proxy Manager and Cloudflare. Available for free at home-assistant. ) happysoul3003. Once you get into zero trust you can setup the tunnel and copy paste the setup script into a Ubuntu based lxc. To quantify this, downloading 1. io. 124. Best practice Tailscale + Cloudflare access. , the Developer Platform, Images, and Stream) that you must use in order to serve video and other large files via the CDN. •. If you want to securely access your stuff, go with Tailscale (or wireguard directly). 8! Personally i just use tailscale as an alternative way to access my public services Hello! I'm running a headscale server on NixOS, and am trying to expose it to the internet with a cloudflare domain and a cloudflare tunnel that is managed by cloudflare itself. I have followed these documentations but they did not help. Check if your cloudflare tunnel still working. I would like to be able to access it remotely. Very easy! I then use tailscale with subnet routing to access my LAN. When setting up an offsite backup solution for your Proxmox server from your office to home, you can explore two main options: VPN site-to-site or Cloudflare tunnels. Cloudflare Tunnel is the easiest way to connect your infrastructure to Cloudflare, whether that be a local HTTP server, web services served by a Kubernetes cluster, or a private network segment. So do I need that I have no issues with removing that part of my setup. I utilize both the Cloudflare reverse proxy and Zero Trust Tunneling services and already utilize HAProxy/Cloudflare reverse proxy for my web service. • 9 days ago. there's 3 different subnets in two places, both sides without real IP address and VPN blocked by ISP, with ability for Port Forwarding using Dynamic DNS or using Tailscale. Some find WireGuard a bit more complicated to setup. Quickconnect simply connects the NAS to the external world. Those peers will be named funnel-ingress-node and are sent with a bit set marking them as funnel peers. Tailscale is probably the best bet - add subnets to it then you can access other machines without having to install on all devices. Tailscale is a device-to-device meshed multiple tunnel wireguard -- free cloud (or self hosted if you are totally paranoid) for simple nerds, like me. Though not exactly sure how that’s done. Subway container will establish a Subway tunnel for the hostnames supplied in the subway label. I saw a poll on here asking how people access their selfhosted resources and only options were VPN or exposing to the web. I like the ease of use for tailscale, but the functionality and performance of twingate is very good. 9. You have Nginx/Traefik in your network. I could use HAProxy or tunnel using Tailscale. Also great for ad blocking on the go without routing all your traffic via home. Check out tailscale. com ) I am running Tailscale in a separate LXC container inside my Proxmox cluster as before i had trouble with TS Container setup. Tailscale is, of course, configured in my home server. 1. html just fine, but any attempt to load a subpage fails. Cloudflare Tunnel is great but it's best paired with a third party identity provider and multiple users. We aim to minimize that gap, and Tailscale generally offers good bandwidth and excellent latency, particularly compared to non-WireGuard VPNs. There is also scenario 3, which is like 2 but with cloudflared running on the VPS so that tunnels can still be used for accessing some or all of your services where Cloudflare fronting makes sense. Just take into consideration for what you are using this tunnel for! Please read the Cloudflare Self-Serve Subscription Agreement, especially section 2. You can even setup two factor auth through cloudflare. I also have cloudflare warp installed on my laptop that I occasionally use to browse internet. The web protection part is good, as is no-vpn access if you use the rest Cloudflare for your web apps and such. Of Cloudflare’s offerings, Cloudflare Access is functionally most similar to Tailscale. Mar 25, 2022 · Our connector. Additionally, Cloudflare tunnels include security features The second thing you can do is have your device’s Tailscale daemon itself terminate TLS. I could connect You can avoid using reverse proxy 100% (I use dashy in my LAN segment) and "punching holes" by using Cloudflare WARP tunnel which is on overlay network over cloudflared. 245. Control server is closed source. nebula :) fly's under the radar but is really easy to setup and 100% selfhosted. 0. 1. i. OpenVPN is a direct tunnel to one machine. Written in Go. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It’s true that both make outbound connections, but Tailscale traffic is over Wireguard encrypted tunnels and cryptographically authenticated, whereas quickconnect traffic is pure plaintext and not even authenticated. I second the recommendation for using Tailscale for remote access to home lab services. 98 foo-phone foo@ android idle, tx 2866076 rx 264724. 79. After 5 minutes, the download over tailscale was only 30% completed. Subway container will generate a DNS mapping in the cloudflare DNS to the tunnel UUID based on the hostname. This would have a VPN set up between the VPS and your raspi at home. 1, you need to adjust the command if it is elsewhere). Gold_Actuator2549. User applications for Linux are open source, Win and Mac are closed source. couple of my friends has access to File Browser Docker +1 for tailscale. ”. Cloudflare DNS Reccord. Source: Done a PoC three times, once when Argo Tunnel was the only tech, then as they started The reality of TCP over TCP is that it just can't be very fast, so you're just not going to get a lot of performance out of any TCP-only VPN solution. Tailscale: This seems like a really easy approach to this problem, however I am sharing my Jellyfin There won't be a solution that does both. For example the VM that runs all my Docker containers or my Proxmox machines. Get help at community. I have this setup. I have a cloudflare record point to my local lan IP and then use caddy to add SSL certs. I'm considering hosting headscale on an oracle free tier VPS just to see if I can eliminate the dependency on tailscale altogether, though I would happily pay for a prosumer level license if one were offered i use jellyfin too but my main complaint is the phone app(s). Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. The third party authentication combined with the weird wizardry it performs definitely feels a little sketchy. There are ways to make even old devices like TVs that can't install Tailscale still access the Tailscale network, involving more advanced topics like advertising routes, but that might be too much for your friends. 168. Tailscale does more than WireGuard, so that will always be true. 0/24 (assuming here your router is at 192. Access allows users to login from anywhere to access protected resources, using their existing identity provider and integrating with their existing endpoint protection. . This moves the inbound HTTP/HTTPs traffic from your IP, to cloudflares, allowing you to know for sure that no traffic is coming to you directly. Tailscale establishes a Wireguard mesh network between your Yeah but I still have to set that up on their devices. Synology Drive vs Tailscale: multiple users accessing a document. The other feature released today enables all of the Jellyfin Client Apps to access your Jellyfin server. Tailscale also does some other stuff (NAT punching, ACL) which makes just adopting the kernel module rather tricky. Then enable it in the web interface, and install on Steam Deck (dont forget the --accept-routes flag). Wireguard is the fastest of those and probably the most secure. That is, you run a webserver on localhost:8080 and we put it on the internet, complete with a public IP address, DNS, TLS cert, and HTTPS server. OpenVPN vs. headscale - Open source implementation of Tailscale control server. The headscale server was previously exposed I'm using cloudflare for SSL and DNS only. Their network also has security protections built in, blocking a variety of threats. In the end I just figured hand managing my wireguard setup was far easier with the tradeoff of giving up on centralized management. It's probably one of the only true peer to peer zero trust solutions out there. However, I am unable to connect to it with an android client using the subdomain set up by the Public Hostname settings. But the difference is, traffic is nearly always peer to peer with Tailscale, so the cost to them is 0, and they can't see what the packets contain, but with Cloudflare, it always traverses their network and the associated cost. I'm not sure, but I think CloudFlare imposes some file size limits for uploads and stuff, but then I think Synology doesn't support all applications via QuickConnect either. The rest is exposed through my Nginx reverse proxy, for which a cloudflare tunnel could be helpful. Now, what confuses me is internal/external dns and internal/external domain. K3CAN. Both of these systems can achieve the same thing, but the difference is more how you think about them. I’ll add a dashboard soon to visualise all apps. cloudflare. Recently, I decided to check the distribution of traffic on my laptop when both Cloudflare warp and tailscale (without any exit node) are enabled, and using wireshark, all the tailscale traffic is reflecting on the cloudflare warp tunnel. Help. The whole setup needs one container and a caddy file that's like 5 lines per domain. It can be useful to hide the origin from a DDOS or whatever similar to the DNS proxying most people do with Cloudflare. Secure and easy to set up :) Tailscale also makes it easy to provide access to internal networks via subnet routing, but it can also be deployed where there is limited or no existing infrastructure. Without exit node only traffic specific to tailscale network will get sent everything else will go out the wifi connection like normal. 3 different subnets in 2 locations. I've tried disabling Cloudflare Tunnel proxy but that just causes the domain not to respond in the web browser (I'm using Cloudflare Tunnel for SSL, etc. Tailscale: I have Tailscale installed on most of my servers and my personal laptop to enable connection regardless of location. Hey guys I have a question would you rather use Tailscale and create a mesh VPN with your home server and other devices or trust cloudflare securing the traffic with SSO to your home services. In the future I will be using Tailscale/Cloudflare tunneling for remote desktop support. there isnt really any one that nails all the features youd want from a streaming app. I use Cloudflare for business websites but have never used the tunnel resource. I tested Tailscale and got 80-100MS Ping; whereas with Ngrok I got 90-240ms. (replace 192. the electron one is the most feature complete but doesnt always work well when its in the background. Client code available with a BSD3 license + separate patents file. WireGuard/Tailscale is designed to allow you to access private resources remotely. After following his guide I was up and running within an hour. Its fallback tunneling/STUN architecture is also completely independent of the C&C servers and runs statelessly. e. Anything with a single purpose, built for that one thing and nothing else, is almost always going to be more efficient. Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. You'll need a hostname and to configure the local IP through the tunnel config on cloudflare zero trust access tab. Tailscale is great but it's not a replacement for Cloudflare Tunnels. If using tailscale make sure your using an exit nodes so all traffic of yours routes through ts and thus goes through the encrypted tunnel. The tunnel can be encrypted (WireGuard, OpenVPN, Tailscale etc. It will function similarly to the cloudflare tunnel but you won't have acces to all the routing Apr 27, 2023 · Apr 27, 2023. If it's just you, I'd stick with Zerotier. Compare Cloudflare Tunnel vs. Tailscale Funnel, I believe only work with, will only work with ports on the local host. Any support is appreciated, and security advice as I'm enough of a newbie to make some big mistakes on that front. Tailscale is supported on a wide range of devices and can be deployed in minutes. Cloudflare does not support media streaming. And I am happy with accessing things over a vpn but I don’t want to have to explain to my gf that she needs to make sure that a vpn is active in order to turn a light on if she’s not home. You would need a server somewhere that is accessible to the internet. Claim ZeroTier and update features and information. You can run WireGuard on PFsense too. 100. Apologies if my English was incoherent it's my second language. You either expose these reverse proxies to internet, with DNS names pointing to your public IP, or you can use cloudflare tunnel to hide your public IP behind the tunnel. I have a vpn set up on my server, that’s not the problem. This allows you to expose your Home Assistant instance and other services to the Internet without opening ports on your router. 118. But Control plane software is closed source, so you can't use it without doing all authentication through their central servers. If two users try and open the same file the second user gets a read only pop up. I use tailscale to access some resources on my local network instead of exposing them to the internet. 76 homeserver foo@ linux -. I wrote a quick post on how I switched from Ngrok to Cloudflare Tunnel to expose apps running on my computer to the Internet, so I can more easily collaborate with colleagues when investigating issues. Unless you are an Enterprise customer, Cloudflare offers specific Paid Services (e. Tailscale is categorically more secure than reverse proxy exposing an open port on your syno unless your IP restrict what can hit this port to a small set of IPs. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. I considered different solutions: setup a cloudflare tunnel: This would work for some dockers, but my main goal is Jellyfin. Tailscale is meant to connect multiple devices together over a secure network. Claim Tailscale and update features and information. And the record seems to be pointing to the server's address. My Jellyfin server got hammered pretty good within an hour or two of setting it up through a Cloudflare tunnel. If you're seeking a suggestion, Vinchin backup recovery software is recognized for its strong backup solutions, which could align well with your requirements The userspace module is an entirely different implementation (written in Go) is slower than the kernel module irrespective of whether it is used in the context of Tailscale or on its own. Easy to use. 0/24 --reset. I have several items that don't confirm to localhost or 127. With Cloudflare Zero Trust, you can manage who can access those webhooks because you can use Service Tokens, which are authentication Headers you add to the request when sending a webhook. ) Things I've tried If you have you might have been thinking of using Cloudflare Tunnel, but giving the key to all your data and traffic to Cloudflare kinda defeat partially the purpose of Self-hosting. Cloudflare’s content delivery network (the “CDN”) Service can be used to cache and serve web pages and websites. My main gripe is the Warp VPN to traditional apps and the setup around that. 1:1000". I use both. Let me know if you have tips I could add to the post :) Tailscale and OpenVPN are two popular Virtual Private Network (VPN) providers. If Nabu Casa does not work this way, I figured it would be more secure, because access to my HA computer would be much harder to find. They work together. 121. MembersOnline. Setup a dynamic dns then use the address to vpn to your home network using port forwarding on your router. tailscale status. Cloudflare Zero Trust is more useful in exposing a HTTP service to the Internet past firewalls and then having rules setup in Cloudflare to adjust access if needed. Cloudflare tunnel - requires a domain name. pv zl mf rn eu rc ci du vh gt